I myself have written from an anti-psychotherapy perspective.
I understand that you hold a very different perspective from me regarding criminal justice. You seem to have misunderstood my perspective, and I’m okay with that.
Yes, my perspective applies to all criminals, including rapists of adults, and murderers: protect society (by incarceration) and attempt rehabilitation; Treat everyone with compassion.
Trauma is a real thing. Trauma can be integrated. Trauma can affect individuals and groups, including whole societies.